An Economy Within View
CANNIBALS: Servants would be our masters. They can only be tyrants. They cannot take responsibility for us. They cannot ponder what is best for us. Instead they are obsessed with themselves. They are weak. They cannot look at what they have done to us. They invent the free-market and individuality and equality. They celebrate while we are harmed.

They degrade us, but wish to gain money to impress us. They are the abusive parent, who demands his child love him, despite his actions. They refuse to accept the responsibility of power, because they are so new to it. They were of the down-trodden, and are now upraised. They are wrongly scared that it will not be for long. They call this “risk”. A thief always fears being robbed: and never is, but never loses the hostility. The hostility of the consciousness of the debt he owed: for having broken the social contract. If a man would rule it must be for the good of the ruled. The Cannibals must pretend their fellow men are but dogs or sheep for the slaughter, and yet cannot admit it.
This is the harsh beauty of the system. If they claimed their money as a matter of racial superiority, they would be destroyed. The Cannibal system does not rest on military might, but only consent. It is a promise: the promise of the servant of God to the lower servant. It says: you too may be a rich man. But that is only to say: leave society. Break the social contract. It is not worth anything. Because for there to be the rich there must be far more poor.
The bored people, from private traumas, who cannot blame their suffering on the perpetrators, but on society at large, take the call. They are the underlings of the numerous managerial class: the sort that never rises to the top. At the top are their abusive fathers: the hedonists and the suicidal.
Their sufferings do not make their relationship to the poor equal. The poor do not benefit. But the poor confuse the lonely devil for an admirer. It is necessary to realize how much cant there is in everything the rich say. Every word is a defense for why you are better off with them having more than you. But it rings hollow. Unresolved with themselves or misanthropic, they never give a thought about the good of people: I mean detached from their material interest. And there can be no compromise between the two.
It cannot, therefore, be them from whom relief is sought. Nor can we hope for a cataclysmic event to occur to take us out of this condition. That religious hope has proven childish from long disappointment. Rather the horror at the incompetence and incoherence of the powerful must be faced; and this can only be done by ceasing to support them: ceasing to need any of them for anything. Having left the social contract, they should not be dealt with.
INDIGENEITY: The Genocide in Palestine has been identified not merely as such, but also as Omnicide. The idea is not merely to destroy a race, but every cultural and economic expression of such. Thus the Olive Trees are destroyed. The Old Places are destroyed. This addition provokes in us a certain pathos; a pathos I would identify as a sense of our own poverty, our own lack of belonging.
I would assert that we have neither a place nor a culture. Whether driven by religious fanaticism, famine, or opportunism, we have left the places whence we came, and continue to move due to our economic system. Simultaneously, and inherent in this way, having left agri-culture we do not have -culture properly speaking. And we seem to have adopted a way of thinking about ourselves that prevents us from gaining one.
It is not uncommon to refer to a person from the word “Indian” to “Native American” as a more accurate and therefore moral and upstanding description. But this is not so. For we are all Native Americans. “Native” means neither more nor less than to be born in a certain place. Any person born in America is a native to that place, and therefore a Native American.
This misnomer is indicative of a certain way of thinking, anti-colonial, which when inverted upon ourselves becomes a permanent assertion that we will never belong where we are. No matter how long we live here, we will never be native, we will never be indigenous. This is not, I would assert, a moral fact, but rather a material one.
What is indigeneity? At the most basic I would identify a people and a place. It comes down to a relationship between the two. What is it? Sufficiency. To be indigenous to a place is to have it suffice for a people. What is the place? I must insist it is where the people live. But how big is “where”? I would assert: within view. Within view is a boundary for a land, and a small one. Perhaps it is unreasonably so, but for mental clarity, I consider it valuable, in contrast to the society we now experience.
What is this? A State, national, global economy. What suffices us is, in short, the world. And that is far out of view, and provides, therefore, no belonging. Being indigenous to the world is a contradiction in terms, only suitable for science fiction. Meanwhile, what is within our view? Land overgrown, land neglected, of no use to us. The moral use of the term “Native American” is a complicity with our global-industrial-service-capitalist-economy.
Separated from the land we assert the impossibility to connect as a virtue. But really this is just a failure to take responsibility. The apparent lack of our impact on the land here is more than compensated by impacts out of view. And I would assert that just as indigeneity is a matter of within view, imperialism is out of view. The complex division of labor that exists in our society leads to many aspects of our lives having elements out of view. Out of view is madness. There is an epistemic break because our senses do not reach there. And so we create a false idea of our impact: but here in the silence of the overgrown land we are as angels.
The division of labor, like that of political power, must be dealt with by establishing the place within view as the totality of place impacted in our interest or in our name. As long as we fail to, we can never be indigenous, can never belong: and therefore will continue to predate other peoples and places.
EMPLOYMENT: Employment is a state of being. It is a relationship. It is an exchange. One person employs another, for money. The one who provides money is active. What is it to be employed? The term can be applied to things: an instrument can be employed for some purpose. Employment is the state of being used for another’s purpose. As humans it is unique in that we have a legally recognized will. Thus we must be convinced to allow ourselves to be employed.
The current state of society is such that without employment it is possible to live, but only quite badly. The governors do not allow taking from the rich, but provide enough aid to maintain a nasty standard for the poor. Today, it is so self-evident that allowing oneself to be employed is vital, that it is not a question whether to do it, but only on what terms. Living well and being employed by someone else have come to be so closely associated that the former has been absorbed into the latter. Thus it is not uncommon to hear politicians promise “more jobs.” This has become the role of the government as far as left-minded persons are concerned: its purpose is to see that more people are employed by other people or by the government itself at higher wages.
In England, the idea can be traced at least to the 1500s. At that time there were “the poor.” These were to be distinguished from the majority of the population, and to be divided. Some were impotent, some willing but unable to find employment. Others were able but unwilling. It is with this middle category and ultimately the latter which certain do-gooders concerned themselves. One way was to give them money. But this was considered demoralizing. Another was to employ them. The defining characteristic was “make work”. They would choose the lowest skill, lowest paying activities: such as pulling apart wool. The idea was rather to keep them from idleness, in anticipation of better employment elsewhere.
Then in the 18th century the idea became common that demand could be increased. The consumers would buy luxuries, which would come to be considered necessities, making room for more luxuries. The poor had been seen as potential criminals or rebels, but increasingly as sources of wealth for the nation. They were being wasted. In the 1800s, as industrialization continued, this group grew, especially in the US. We were a century behind, but by 1900 there was a close resemblance with England in urban centers.
In the early 20th century, the combination of war and speculation caused massive fluctuations in demand. The accepted solution was that the government should spend money. Here, before, it had been assumed the poor were a minority. Now, with sudden unemployment, everyone was in that category. It was not considered necessary to shift to communism, however, but merely to get the market back where it had been. Here was make-work on a large scale. One could, however, describe the so-called “depression” rather as a return to reality, than an evil to be escaped. It came after a war and speculation. Both of these cause higher demand. When they end, all those supplying it are unemployed. There is a labor glut.
We are a society obsessed with decreasing labor cost; or let us say that is the capitalist’s program. He wishes to replace the native worker with machines and cheap foreigners. The result is a continual displacement. Farmers today are the capitalists. They invest heavily not only in machinery but pesticides and fertilizer. They are able to farm enormous tracts of land virtually alone, with the aid of a little migrant labor. The population must “go elsewhere.” There has been a mass exodus to industry. But that was brief and quickly glutted by machines, cheap labor and offshoring.
This continual “going elsewhere” is make-work. The most obvious problem is global warming. In many cases the paid activity is not destructive: services, for instance. They involve talking, handing things, using instruments. But the auxiliary activities are destructive. They commute. Their office buildings must be heated and powered. Then in turn the old activities, such as agriculture, use non-human energy in their absence. The tableau is a surplus class supported by petroleum. From a merely ecological and self-respecting point of view, this must stop. Perhaps we should consider another way. How? Don’t make work. Get what you need directly, minimize expenses.
FAMILIAR LABOR: We live in a society characterized by alienation and displacement. In the not too distant past, this was contrasted with “the home”, where labor was not sold, and which was by definition the antithesis of displacement. This place was purportedly that of the wife/mother. She was supposed to be the carrier of culture and morals, in contrast to the cold-hearted self-interest in society. Such an image has been whole-heartedly destroyed on the principle that male-female relations were unequal, because money is the measure of power.
As such the role of the wife has increasingly disappeared and been replaced with commodity substitutes.
Thus food is prepared to eat before sale, cleaning processes have been mechanized, child- and aged- care have been outsourced. In short, the last bastion of what I would call “familiar labor” has been greatly reduced. Is this a bad thing? There was sickness already.
The problem began not with the woman leaving the household, but with the man leaving it. And this was idealized: the breadwinner. Alienation was already there to replace familiar bonds with professional duties. Two steps back would be a context that is sustainable, because it does not involve movement. Movement of goods comes with movement of labor. Mechanization follows expansion of markets and the energy expended on transportation. The focal point of the home as a sanctuary was already a degradation of its status, as the origin of consciousness. Instead of a self-sustaining unit it was already an ornament.
Income inequality is the short-sighted decadent foundation for the current concept of gender equality. Instead of finding ways to decrease expense and consumption, or replace them with non-monetary local alternatives, a sustainable and culture building effort, there is a mad rush to increase incomes: not on the basis of need, but as a matter of honor. What would that ultimately achieve? Once there is income parity will there be heaven on earth? Likely no. Instead climate collapse and social confusion will merely continue. It is time to get off the gravy-train logic of capitalism.
Rather, familiar labor must be recognized for what it is: a threat. Labor that cannot be bought and sold is that much less leverage for the employer. It is the law of supply and demand.
By doubling the labor force, with the entrance of women, the employer is able to pay half. Then too, the commodification of life increases the amount of money circulating, and thus available capital. Every little part of the human condition is bought and sold. The growth-model essence of our current systems requires both capital and labor.
The death blow to it would involve a retraction of labor from the market, and satisfaction of needs directly by it. The question should not be: does the woman return to the household. Rather, shall we take the good of the past and distinguish it from sickly idolization of domestic life; shall we recognize domesticity or placed-ness in potential as a parallel and competing economic system. “Economy” or “Eco”-“nomos” is, after all, merely the science of “household”-“management”.
FREEDOM: Material conditions define the limits of consciousness: the thoughts that can be had. And the farther thoughts roam from these limits, that is madness. As a better way of life requires more different material conditions that way is less considered, with the consequence that the discontented seek to cram their ideals into the status quo, in the form of events or temporary revolution. Any enduring better way of life will require a systematic shift, which is at once disparate and holistic.
What is a better way of life? Let us suggest it is, most pragmatically and boringly, one in which the cost of living is reduced, with the ultimate goal being to live comfortably for no money. As a disparate measure to this principle, let one examine the major common expenses: housing, transportation, food, insurance, utilities. If one is to reduce the whole, one must reduce the parts. And the parts in turn consist of still smaller parts.
Let us take housing, for instance. There is the cost to acquire and maintain a house. Meanwhile maintenance is contractual, human caused, and physical, nature caused. Contractual maintenance concerns rent or property taxes. Whereas physical maintenance regards any expenses for keeping the building sound, as painting or roof repair. In the scenario of ownership this is prefixed with the great cost of acquisition. Having gone down this rabbit hole, we can observe, first, that there are many factors, so that one must prioritize or be drowned. This can be done in two ways: by the proportional magnitude of some part, or by the personal preference for it.
There is also the matter of self-interest which should not, I think, be neglected. When self-interest is taken as an evil, and selflessness attempted, the process is ultimately prioritized and results neglected. Thus a homeowner will not be interested in rent control, and possibly even averse to it. One should not view these tensions as enduring, and certainly they are not to be neglected: for to reduce expenses reduces the need to price gouge, with the only excuse becoming greed.
I am, for instance, a homeowner, and therefore concerned with property tax. Property tax is the only limit or service obstructing my absolute legal security in this land. Having selected this component expense of housing - which impacts renters indirectly - I am then led in another direction of enquiry. The tax is for something. Tax money goes to schools, roads, fire and police - primarily. Any attempt to reduce property tax must thus reduce the cost of these. Which then introduces the questions about their extent, necessity and formulation.
If one chooses education, for instance, one is knocking at the door of the highest fetish of liberalism: the training of our future, essential if progress is to continue. Likewise it is the other occurrence of socialism in America besides elderly and poor care - care of children. Meanwhile having settled on this spot, with whatever success it might entail, one must be wary that other expenses do not consume any savings.
Thus the advent of food mass-production reduced the cost of food, but one might say this has been more than compensated by that of increased housing cost. Another danger which this first one introduces is that the forest will be lost for the trees. Thus a reduction in food prices was achieved at the cost of introducing a destructive form of Agriculture. This factor, so easily ignored by the communist and capitalist, must not be forgotten: that in the way to replace these expensive options with cheaper ones there must not develop a destructiveness: of pesticides, GMOs, endocrine disrupters. And moreover it is often the siloed quality of reform which makes any change proposal so unappealing to anyone in their right mind.
What I have proposed, this project of expense-reduction - to live “for free” - is perhaps all the more daunting for having been proposed. And yet I think it salutary to contemplate the challenge in its totality. Ultimately any person can likely contribute to a part of the project. But it must, I think, be asked. For as we accept almost automatically that expenses will go up, we must remember that our grandparents were richer than our parents, and our parents richer than us; that a unique period of affluence occurred after WWII which is unlikely to recur any time soon; but that instead we will likely come to resemble England: a degraded post-imperial wasteland, if we do not find a way to live nobly on less money.

TOWN FARM: A project in which I am engaged, and give as an example, I call Town Farm. The idea is to combine the logic of the community garden, people growing their own food, with the methods of small-scale commercial agriculture. Both models have problems. The first has failed to enable people to grow a significant proportion of the food they consume, if that was ever even a goal. The second, as part of the local food movement, has failed to dominate the market, providing at most 20% of food, with the rest being provided by national and international systems. Moreover there tends to be a premium. But the first model is a recognized example of what I have called “familiar labor”, or doing something not for money but the fruit of labor. The methods of the second have been disciplined by the market, to a higher labor efficiency, which methods are, I posit, necessary for typical people, working a 9-5 job, to have sufficient time to grow a significant portion of their own food. The result of this marriage should be a modernized subsistence farming method. People will come together, and thus recreate a demand similar to small-commercial, which then legitimizes the economies of scale, while simultaneously this group will not sell but rather eat the fruits. The steps in order as I see them at this time are:
1. Identify interested land-owners of cleared land in Williamsburg (my town).
2. Create a data-base identifying interested owners, owners’ terms, land characteristics and potential crops.
3. Identify ideal acre for topography, soil quality, land-owner terms, access to water.
4. Identify approximately 40 residents interested in participating in a novel food project, preferably living close to the selected acre.
5. Identify growing methods and hours of labor acceptable to these participating residents.
6. Create a pilot “Town Farm” on this acre of land.
a. Analyze current availability of agricultural machinery and other growing aids in Williamsburg, including any manure resources, including per/hr use or operation of a tractor for plowing and disking.
b. Identify “best pricing” for any necessary purchases: seed, irrigation equipment, fencing, etc.
c. Achieve significant food self-sufficiency for growers of this acre, with an emphasis on the “off-season gap”, from mid-Fall to early-Summer: potatoes, carrots, onions, garlic, squash.
d. Build a passive root cellar for the growers, or identify other storage options.
e. Use sustainable practices: soil health, water conservation, non-gmo seeds, avoid synthetic herbicides, pesticides and fertilizers, etc.
f. Develop a refined system of cooperation.
7. Develop a federation of “Town Farms” in Williamsburg for all those interested in having land in agricultural use, and those interested in growing.
8. Coordinate resources of this Federation of Town Farms.

